Act I, Scene 2
1) In scene two, people celebrate and congratulate
Claudius for becoming a new king. Everyone was really excited and most people
wore really bright cloth to show how happy they are with this decision.
Everyone, but Hamlet. Even though he is one of the representatives of the royal
family and he had to stand next to his parents, Branagh decides to isolate him
from everyone else and Hamlet is the only person who wears all black in the
whole crowd. Hamlet is clearly disappointed with his mother’s decision to marry
his uncle and he does not want to be a part of this wedding. I think that it was a wise decision because
the audience understands how different Hamlet is from his family.
2) I think that it was not a wise decision to have
Claudius, Gertrude and Hamlet to have this conversation about the death of
Hamlet Senior in the middle of the wedding. It is a really important problem and
I think it would have been better if they had this family time alone and not in
front of this huge group of people. I don’t think it is possible to be honest with
someone about your feelings if they are other people listening to what you are
saying. But I guess Branagh highlights “Pretense & Performance” theme by
having the actors participate in this discussion at such an inconvenient time;
because Claudius and Gertrude can say really encouraging things in front of the
whole kingdom, but they do not have to necessarily mean that. They can just
pretend that they really care about Hamlet’s position and his feelings. It looked like they were lying, because Gertrude
had a really rapid eye movement, and there was no eye contact between Hamlet
and Claudius.
Act I, Scene 3
1) At the end of scene three, Ophelia says: “I
shall obey my lord”. She did not address this line to her father. Before she
said that sentence, the audience saw a few shock cuts of Ophelia having sex
with Hamlet. In my opinion, it is a very clever technique that Branagh used to deliver
this line. Everything was more than just flirting between Ophelia and Hamlet. After
Polonius hit his daughter and talked to her in such a demanding way, Ophelia
decided to continue being this rebellious teenager and not follow her fathers’
orders.
2) I think that Laertes should have never kissed
Ophelia’s lips, because it looked creepy and weird. Laertes looked really
attracted to his sister. He was really close to her and stared at her lips the
whole time. He was very playful and that was just wrong.
I like how you assessed the meaning of Branagh's decisions in your first two responses. You made relevant and interesting connections to themes. Do the same thing in your second two responses. You also need to use key film terms like character highlight as you write about the film.
ReplyDelete